| Role | Name | Name (original language) | Name (translation) | Floruits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Accused | Patrick (II), earl of Dunbar (d.1248) | None | Earl Patrick | 1208 × 1248 |
| Juror | Robert, earl of Strathearn (1223-45) | earl of Strathearn | 1200 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Robert Bruce V, lord of Annandale (d.1295) | Robert de Brus | 1237 × 1294 | |
| Juror | William, son of Earl Patrick (I) (d.1253) | William, brother of Earl Patrick | 1210 × 1250 | |
| Juror | William Gifford, sheriff of Edinburgh | William Giffard | 1237 × 1247 | |
| Juror | Roger de Mowbray | Roger de Moubray | 1212 × 1263 | |
| Juror | David de Bonville, marischal (fl.late 12C-mid13C) | David Marshal | 1182 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Richard, marischal, knight (TRA) | Richard Marshal | 1245 × 1253 | |
| Juror | Robert, marischal (mid 13C) | Robert Marshal | 1245 × 1273 | |
| Juror | John of Keith, marischal (son of Hervey) | John of Keith | 1245 × 1272 | |
| Juror | Ness Fraser | Ness Fraser | 1245 × 1259 | |
| Juror | Laurence Fraser, knight (son of Adam) | Laurence Fraser | 1231 × 1248 | |
| Juror | Robert de Mowbray (13C) | Robert de Moubray | 1245 × 1247 | |
| Juror | Philip le Brun | Philip le Brun | 1245 × 1247 | |
| Juror | John de Aunay | John d’Aunay | 1244 × 1245 | |
| Juror | William of Ormiston | William of Ormiston | 1244 × 1245 | |
| Juror | Adam of Yetholm, knight | Adam of Yetholm | 1241 × 1244 | |
| Juror | William de Vieuxpont, son of Emma or son of Matilda (13C) | William de Vieuxpont | 1219 × 1244 | |
| Juror | David Graham (III), sheriff of Berwick (d.c.1272) | David of Graham | 1220 × 1259 | |
| Juror | William, son of the earl | William, son of the earl | 1245 × 1248 | |
| Juror | Robert of Congalton (13C) | Robert of Congalton | 1190 × 1244 | |
| Juror | David of Berndun | David of Berndun | 1244 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Walter of Berndun | Walter of Berndun | 1244 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Philip of Pitcox, steward of Earl Patrick (II) | Philip of Pitcox | 1189 × 1244 | |
| Juror | John, son of Waltheof | John son of Waltheof | 1232 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Robert of Wilton (12/13C) | Robert of Wilton | 1188 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Adam Gordon II, knight, son of Adam | Adam of Gordon | 1182 × 1290 | |
| Juror | Alan Sinclair, knight | Alan de St Clare | 1189 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Thomas de Normanville, knight | Thomas de Normanville | 1228 × 1254 | |
| Juror | Waleran de Normanville (d.1253) | Waleran his brother | 1240 × 1244 | |
| Juror | John of Hermiston | John of Hermiston | 1245 × 1251 | |
| Juror | David Oliphant (13C) | David Olifard | 1215 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Patrick Melville | Patrick de Maleville | 1244 × 1245 | |
| Juror | William of Mordington | William of Mordington | 1210 × 1248 | |
| Juror | Hector (Eachann)(13C) | Hector (sic) | 1244 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Waltheof of Strachan | Waltheof of Strachan | 1182 × 1244 | |
| Juror | William Balliol (mid-13C) | William de Balliol | 1239 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Simon Lockhart, son of Malcolm Lockhart | Simon Lockhart | 1245 × 1273 | |
| Juror | Robert of Kippo | Robert of Kippo | 1241 × 1244 | |
| Juror | Richard la Mahille | Richard la Mahille | 1244 × 1244 | |
| Accused | Walter Comyn, earl of Menteith (d.1258) | Earl Walter Comyn | 1213 × 1258 | |
| Juror | Nicholas Soulis, lord of Liddesdale (d.1265) | None | Nicholas de Soules | 1234 × 1263 |
| Juror | Gilbert Hay (I), lord of Errol (d.1263) (son of David) | None | Gilbert de la Haye | 1198 × 1263 |
| Juror | Robert Menzies, chamberlain (d.1267) | None | Robert de Menzies | 1231 × 1267 |
| Juror | John Comyn, lord of Badenoch (d.1277) | None | John Comyn | 1231 × 1272 |
| Juror | William de Vieuxpont, son of Emma or son of Matilda (13C) | None | William de Vieuxpont | 1219 × 1244 |
| Juror | David Comyn, lord of Kilbride (d.1247) | None | David Comyn | 1223 × 1244 |
| Juror | Richard (III) de Munfichet (Muschet) | None | Richard de Munfichet | 1244 × 1245 |
| Juror | William of Airth, lord of Fordell | None | William of Airth | 1240 × 1258 |
| Juror | Malcolm, son of the earl | None | Malcolm son of the earl | 1244 × 1244 |